Allow Change Payment Method to Automated Recurring Gifts

We want to be able to change the payment method for our credit card recurring gifts that were automated. Blackbaud support confirmed that in order to do so, we need to complete/terminate the existing Recurring Gift and create a new one.


This is not ideal as we then lose the information on how long a constituent has been a consistent recurring giver.

  • Leanne Marsh
  • Sep 25 2022
  • Reviewed: Voting Open
  • Attach files
  • Jason Barfield commented
    24 Sep 14:49

    This has to be changed. Donors often need to change their payment method, beyond updating credit card or bank details. They may want to switch from Bill Me to a credit card, from a credit card to ACH, or back to Bill Me.

    Currently, changing the payment method on a pledge requires writing it off, which artificially increases write-offs. Changing it on a recurring gift requires terminating and re-adding the gift, which unnecessarily adds entries to the donor’s record and can create gaps in consecutive payments.

  • Guest commented
    03 Aug 17:16

    We have many donors that call wanting to switch from credit/debit card payment on their recurring gift to ACH or check as their card information was stolen. Others open their recurring gift with a credit/debit card only to change their mind a month later and want to send checks instead. Opening and closing recurring gifts after they were opened only one month ago is not ideal for reporting purposes, for such having this functionality would be best for donor tracking, continuity and financial reporting.

  • Jack Wagner commented
    May 08, 2025 20:56

    Our users made the same request. The ability to change from credit card to ACH or debit is needed.

  • Lee Bailey commented
    September 26, 2022 00:05

    This is recently become an increasing request from donors with scamming becoming so sophisticated

  • Guest commented
    September 25, 2022 23:38

    Excellent idea - the last thing we want is to lose valuable constituent data.